US Judge Rejects Exxon, Shell Nigeria Case

By Jonathan Stempel
Wednesday, September 4, 2019

A U.S. judge on Wednesday rejected Exxon Mobil Corp's and Royal Dutch Shell Plc's effort to revive a $1.8 billion arbitration award against Nigeria's state-run oil company, which stemmed from a dispute over a 1993 contract to extract oil near the African country's coastline.

U.S. District Judge William Pauley in Manhattan cited public policy and due process considerations in deciding not to enforce the October 2011 award against Nigerian National Petroleum Corp (NNPC), which was subsequently set aside by courts in Nigeria.

"While this court may have inherent authority to fashion appropriate relief in certain circumstances, exercising that authority to create a $1.8 billion judgment is a bridge too far," Pauley wrote in a 50-page decision.

The companies said last November that the award had grown to $2.67 billion, including interest.

Exxon spokesman Todd Spitler said the Irving, Texas-based company disagreed with the decision and was evaluating its next steps. Shell and its lawyers did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

"NNPC is very pleased with the decision, and was always confident that there was no basis for a U.S. court to confirm the award," its lawyer Cecilia Moss said in an interview.

According to court papers, the 1993 contract anticipated that Exxon and Shell affiliates would invest billions of dollars to extract oil from the Erha field, about 60 miles (97 km) off Nigeria's coast, and share profits with NNPC.

But the affiliates, Esso Exploration and Production Nigeria Ltd and Shell Nigeria Exploration and Production Co Ltd, accused NNPC of unilaterally "lifting" more oil than was contractually allowed, at the behest of Nigeria's government, depriving them of billions of dollars of oil.

Pauley said Exxon and Shell still have "multiple appeals pending" in Nigeria, and rejected their argument that it might be difficult to collect there.

Exxon and Shell "executed a contract in Nigeria with another Nigerian corporation containing an arbitration clause requiring any arbitration to be held in Nigeria under Nigerian law, and it then sought to confirm the award in Nigeria," Pauley wrote. " cannot now reasonably complain that efforts to collect will be frustrated in Nigeria."

In an Aug. 7 regulatory filing, Exxon said it did not expect the case to materially affect its operations or financial condition.

The case is Esso Exploration and Production Nigeria Ltd et al v Nigerian National Petroleum Corp, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 14-08445.


(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel; Editing by Matthew Lewis and Richard Chang)

Categories: Legal Africa

Related Stories

Shell Brings Deepwater Gas Fields Onstream off Malaysia

Orlen's Termination of Qatar LNG Deal Could Yield $2B in Savings

Inpex Raises Profit Forecast on Strong Ichthys LNG Production

Aramco’s Building in Riyadh Damaged by Houthi Attack

Tender-Assist Rigs: Southeast Asia’s Quiet Workhorses Head for Full Utilization

TotalEnergies Inks 15-Year LNG Supply Deal with China's Jiangsu Guoxin

Production Restart at Australian Offshore Fields Boosts Jadestone's Oil Output

Aramco Targets Hormuz Bypass with East-West Pipeline Expansion

ADES Lands New Offshore Drilling Rig Deals in Angola and Indonesia

Seadrill Secures Offshore Drilling Deals Across Four Countries

Current News

When Contractors Collide: Keeping Offshore Energy Projects on Schedule

Floating Production Outlook: Pipeline Looks Huge, But Not All Projects Are Created Equal

Shell Brings Deepwater Gas Fields Onstream off Malaysia

Hanwha Power Secures FSRU Conversion Deal with Energos

Orlen's Termination of Qatar LNG Deal Could Yield $2B in Savings

Oil Heads for Weekly Decline Despite Middle East Supply Threats

Inpex Raises Profit Forecast on Strong Ichthys LNG Production

Singapore Seeks LNG Floating Storage Operators to Expand Bunkering Ops

CNOOC Makes Ultra-Deep Gas Discovery in China's Bohai Sea

First Oil Flows from Vietsovpetro's Platform Offshore Vietnam

Magazine

Subscribe for AOG Digital E‑News

AOG Digital E-News is the subsea industry's largest circulation and most authoritative ENews Service, delivered to your Email three times per week

https://accounts.newwavemedia.com