Australia Court Ruling on Santos Raises Risks for Offshore Gas Projects

Sonali Paul
Friday, December 2, 2022

Australia's Federal Court rejected on Friday an appeal by Santos Ltd to resume drilling on its $3.6 billion Barossa gas project off northern Australia after indigenous groups raised objections, potentially delaying other offshore projects.

Three Federal Court judges ruled that Santos had not consulted all the indigenous people on the Tiwi Islands that should have been consulted for its environmental plan, backing a challenge brought by a member of the Munupi clan.

The court's decision means all offshore developers will have to consult a wide range of groups, including those with cultural interests, when seeking regulatory approvals, which could slow projects in the works such as Woodside Energy Group's $12 billion Scarborough gas development and linked Pluto LNG plant expansion.

"There is now the risk of more delays and obstacles in the progression of important energy projects," Australian Petroleum Production and Exploration Association Chief Executive Samantha McCulloch said in a statement.

The court's ruling hit the companies' shares. Santos closed down 3.8%, and Woodside ended 2.6% lower in a broader market that fell just 0.7%.

Santos on Friday said it would apply for fresh approvals for its biggest project in line with the court's order.

"Santos does not anticipate any material cost or schedule impact, and first gas from the Barossa Gas Project remains on track to be delivered in the first half of 2025," the company said in a statement.

The court backed a challenge led by Munupi clan member Dennis Tipakalippa, who contended that the Barossa project posed a risk to sacred sites and spiritual connection to Sea Country north of the Tiwi Islands in the Timor Sea.

"Our sea is like our mother - we are part of the sea and the sea is part of us. Santos and every other gas company must take note that this is our country and we must be consulted," Tipakalippa said in a statement after the court handed down its decision.

The Barossa gas field is about 140 km north of the Tiwi Islands.

Santos had to suspend drilling on the project in September after a judge found that the environmental approval by the National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority (NOPSEMA) for the Barossa permit was invalid as it had not properly consulted the Munupi clan about the project.

Tipakalippa's lawyer told the court Santos should have gone beyond the Tiwi Land Council to talk to people who had a specific interest in Sea Country, just as Santos had talked to groups that had fishing and tourist interests.

Santos said it had consulted all the relevant persons who might be affected by its drilling and that it would be too hard to consult all indigenous groups with connections to the area.

But in their decision, the three Federal Court judges concluded: "In this case, we consider it clear that Mr Tipakalippa and the Munupi clan had interests ... that required them to be consulted."

Credit Suisse analyst Saul Kavonic said the court's decision "may cause a material delay to Barossa, as a new consultation process is undertaken and a new environmental plan is submitted and assessed by NOPSEMA".

A lawyer at the Environmental Defenders Office, Alina Leikin, said her Tiwi Island clients including Tipakalippa do not want drilling in the Timor Sea, but that would be a matter for the consultation process.

"The community are hopeful that the regulator and Santos will understand and appreciate the depth of their concern and their desire to protect their Sea Country and won't go ahead with this drilling," Leikin told Reuters by phone from the Tiwi Islands.


(Reuters - Reporting by Sonali Paul; Editing by Muralikumar Anantharaman and Edmund Klamann)


Categories: Energy Drilling Industry News Activity Production Australia/NZ

Related Stories

CNOOC Puts Into Production New Oil Field in South China Sea

CNOOC Starts Production at Two New Oil and Gas Projects

Shell Hires Noble’s Drillship for Work in Southeast Asia

Sapura Energy Nets $720M from Multiple Drilling Services Contracts

SLB Names Raman CSO, CMO

CNOOC Boosts Dongfang Gas Fields Output with New Platform Coming Online

BP Targets 44% Oil, 89% Gas Increase from India’s Mumbai High Field

US Operator Finds Oil Offshore Vietnam

BP to Help Boost Oil and Gas Output at India’s Largest Producing Field

CNOOC’s South China Sea Oil Field Goes On Stream

Current News

Shell-Reliance-ONGC JV Complete India’s First Offshore Decom Project

The Future of Long-Idle Drillships: Cold-Stacked or Dead-Stacked?

TMC Books Compressors Orders for FPSO and LNG Vessels

MODEC, Sumitomo Partner Up for Delivery of Gato do Mato FPSO

Chuditch Gas Field Up for Summer Drilling Ops as Sunda Reshapes Ownership Structure

EnQuest Bags Two Production Sharing Contracts off Indonesia

Hanwha Drilling’s Tidal Action Drillship En Route to Petrobras’ Roncador Field

China's ENN, Zhenhua Oil Ink LNG Supply Deals with ADNOC

MODEC Wins ExxonMobil Guyana’s Hammerhead FPSO Contract

India Stretches Bids Deadline for 13 Offshore Deep-Sea Mineral Blocks

Subscribe for AOG Digital E‑News

AOG Digital E-News is the subsea industry's largest circulation and most authoritative ENews Service, delivered to your Email three times per week

https://accounts.newwavemedia.com