Size Matters in Shale Industry

Shailaja A. Lakshmi
Sunday, February 10, 2019

Having taken a closer look at the detailed economics of the most recent 1,000 wells drilled in the most popular shale hotspot – the Wolfcamp A zone of the Permian Delaware basin – Rystad Energy can see a clear pattern emerging that favors large players.

As US crude production is set to grow significantly over the next decade, analysts still debate whether shale drilling is actually a profitable endeavor. Some skeptics claim operators overstate their well production profiles, while others say operational cash flow from shale wells will never be sufficient to cover corporate costs and old debt.

Analysts and investors are now waiting to see fourth quarter earnings as an acid test on profitable growth in the Permian basin at lower oil prices.

Quarterly results have already been published by ExxonMobil, Chevron and Anadarko, of which only Chevron appeared to generate positive cash flow from operations in the Permian basin. ExxonMobil and Anadarko, on the other hand, seemed to still be in investment mode in the play.

Rystad Energy believes net cash is now likely in the red for many smaller oil companies that focus entirely or predominantly on the Permian basin.

“Our conclusion is that the average well completed during 2017 and 2018, which mirrors the most likely production profile and costs, appears very profitable even at local oil prices of $45 per barrel,” said Rystad Energy senior partner Per Magnus Nysveen.

He added: “However, there are also many wells that will not be profitable at this price level, and drilling needs to be conducted on a large scale in order to secure robust cash flows even in the hottest play. Betting on a low number of wells could give more uncertain returns than rolling the dice at the nearest casino.”

Operators with scaled operations and large acreage positions exposed to Wolfcamp A in the Permian Delaware should see average returns of 20% and three years’ payback from new wells, even with WTI Midland oil prices at $45 per barrel. Smaller operators, on the other hand, would face higher costs for drilling, completion, operation and transport, and also lower realized oil prices.

“These operators might struggle in the current price environment, and their best opportunity to monetize their investment could be to sell their acreage to larger operators with more efficient logistics, better infrastructure and more negotiating power through the value chain,” Nysveen said. “Size matters, even more so when drilling for shale oil in the Permian Basin.”

Categories: Shale Oil & Gas Shale Research

Related Stories

SPE Offshore Europe 2025 set to drive transformational change for the energy sector

Saipem Marks First Steel Cut for Tangguh UCC Project at Karimun Yard

Shelf Drilling Lands New Jack-Up Contract in Vietnam, Extends Egypt Deal

Seatrium Engages Axess Group to Clear FPSOs for Brazil Deployment

Sapura Energy Rebrands to Vantris Energy

CNOOC Brings New Offshore Gas Field On Stream

PTTEP Buys Chevron's Hess Unit Share of Southeast Asia’s Offshore Block for $450M

SBM Offshore’s Jaguar FPSO Enters Drydock in Singapore (Video)

EnQuest Picks Up Offshore Oil and Gas Block in Brunei

Seatrium Makes First Turnkey FPSO Delivery to Petrobras

Current News

SPE Offshore Europe 2025 set to drive transformational change for the energy sector

Shipbuilder Delivers Fast Crew Boat Pair to Aesen

Norwegian Oil Investment Will Peak in '25

Saipem Marks First Steel Cut for Tangguh UCC Project at Karimun Yard

Saipem Wins FEED Contract For Abadi LNG Project FPSO Module In Indonesia

Cheniere, JERA Ink Long-Term LNG Sale and Purchase Agreement

Shelf Drilling Lands New Jack-Up Contract in Vietnam, Extends Egypt Deal

Seatrium Engages Axess Group to Clear FPSOs for Brazil Deployment

Inpex Picks FEED Contractors for Abadi LNG Onshore Plant

Inpex Kicks Off FEED Work for Abadi LNG Scheme Offshore Indonesia

Subscribe for AOG Digital E‑News

AOG Digital E-News is the subsea industry's largest circulation and most authoritative ENews Service, delivered to your Email three times per week

https://accounts.newwavemedia.com