Schlumberger Fights to Boost Patent Damages at US Supreme Court

By Andrew Chung
Monday, April 16, 2018

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday appeared divided over whether to make it easier for companies to recoup profits lost due to the unauthorized use of their patented technology overseas in a dispute involving Schlumberger NV, the world's largest oilfield services provider.

The nine justices heard about an hour of arguments that will resolve the amount of money that rival ION Geophysical Corp must pay for infringing Schlumberger technology that helps search for oil and gas beneath the ocean floor. Both companies are based in Houston.

Some justices, including conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch and liberal Justice Stephen Breyer, expressed concerns about applying U.S. patent laws abroad, while others indicated that Schlumberger should be fully compensated.

Schlumberger is appealing a lower court ruling that barred it from recovering $93.4 million in lost profits stemming from foreign contracts the company said it missed out on as a result of the infringement.

Schlumberger said federal patent law protects against infringement that occurs when components of a patented invention are supplied from the United States for assembly abroad, and so it should be fully compensated for its lost foreign sales.

Gorsuch and Breyer expressed skepticism about imposing damages based on the use of the technology by ION's overseas customers. Breyer said if other countries did the same it could pose problems for U.S. companies as well.

"I see chaos or confusion," Breyer said.

Conservative Justices Samuel Alito and Anthony Kennedy, as well as liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor, signaled sympathy for Schlumberger.

Kennedy told ION's attorney Kannon Shanmugam that the company's position would confine patent owners in how they use their own patents and mean they would not be fully compensated for infringement. Shanmugam said that U.S. patent laws have a "presumption against extraterritoriality."

A decision in Schlumberger's favor would expand the ability of patent owners to recover foreign-based damages, increasing the threat posed by certain infringement suits in the United States.

Schlumberger said that the lower court ruling harms innovation by allowing companies to infringe competitors' patents while risking minimal punishment.

Other observers, including a group representing internet-based companies, said the opposite is true because extending patent damages beyond national borders would expose U.S. high-technology firms to greater patent-related risks overseas.

The case involves four patents owned by Schlumberger subsidiary WesternGeco related to an invention that more efficiently completes marine seismic surveys to help identify oil and gas drilling locations.

ION developed a competing system and sold it to surveying companies abroad. WesternGeco sued in 2009, and a federal jury in Houston found that Ion infringed the patents and caused the company to lose contracts. The jury awarded $12.5 million in royalties as well as the $93.4 million in lost profits.

In 2015, the Washington-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which specializes in patent disputes, ruled that Schlumberger could not recoup the lost profits portion, saying U.S. patent law does not apply outside the country.

President Donald Trump's administration backed Schlumberger, and urged the justices to overturn the lower court ruling, which it said "systematically undercompensates" U.S. patent owners who participate in cross-border commerce.

The justices are due to issue their ruling by the end of June.


(Reporting by Andrew Chung; Editing by Will Dunham)

Categories: Legal Technology(Energy) Offshore Energy Technology Finance Offshore Energy

Related Stories

Woodside and Jera Agree LNG Cargoes Supply for Japan’s Winter Period

Japanese Oil and Gas Firm Enters Two Blocks off Malaysia

MODEC and Terra Drone Renew FPSO Drone Inspection Partnership

BW Opal FPSO Vessel set for Work off Australia

Keyfield Ventures into Indonesia’s Oil and Gas Market with New Partner

ABS Greenlights SHI’s Multi-Purpose Deepwater LNG Floating Unit

Scarborough FPU's Topsides and Hull Come Together in Major Engineering Feat (Video)

TMC Books Compressors Orders for FPSO and LNG Vessels

MODEC Wins ExxonMobil Guyana’s Hammerhead FPSO Contract

MODEC and Samsung Team Up to Install Carbon Capture Tech on FPSO

Current News

CNOOC Signs Hydrocarbons Exploration and Production Deal with Kazakhstan

Thailand's PTT to Buy LNG from Glenfarne's Alaska LNG Project

Woodside and Jera Agree LNG Cargoes Supply for Japan’s Winter Period

Petronas Expands Suriname Portfolio with Deepwater Block Acquisition

Japanese Oil and Gas Firm Enters Two Blocks off Malaysia

Yinson Production, “K” LINE Target Europe's CCS with FSIU and LCO2 Solutions

Woodside Agrees Long-Term LNG Supply with Petronas Unit

MODEC and Terra Drone Renew FPSO Drone Inspection Partnership

Yinson Production Closes $1B Investment to Drive Further Growth

Petronas-Eni Upstream Joint Venture to Take Up to Two Years to Set Up

Subscribe for AOG Digital E‑News

AOG Digital E-News is the subsea industry's largest circulation and most authoritative ENews Service, delivered to your Email three times per week

https://accounts.newwavemedia.com